Can you be a Manager to someone and at the same time be their coach? This is tricky. Coaching relies on trust, on the success of establishing a partnership. However, when we coach, we are almost living two different roles at the same time. We are equal AND unequal. Let’s dive in and explore what that means!
EQUAL:
There’s an obvious way how Leader Coaches are unequal to their team members as coaches. Leader Coaches are still Line Managers. The coached Team Member is in a position of dependency. When we coach, we want to establish enough trust and safety, so that the status difference between us is almost entirely removed. Coaching relies on a partnership of equality between coach and client, so that either can share what’s on their mind, agree or disagree with the other person, without fearing being reprimanded.
How does a coach establish equality and safety? We make explicit offers to the other person to counter our arguments, to disagree with us, for example. We also ask people specifically about how well the coaching approach work for them and what they would like to do less or more. This alone is an eye-opener for clients, who never thought they could challenge their coach!
UNEQUAL:
While we strive to be equal in status to our coachee, we are also unequal. And this refer to the distinctly different role we have as coach, compared to our coachee. Yes, we partner equally in status, but what we bring in to the conversation is very different. The Coachee is the expert in the topic, in the problem to be solved. What is the coach’s role then? We are the expert in the process of coaching and no more. It is central to ethical practice.
In summary, the best kind of coaching maintains this duality. We are equal, safe and partnering. We are also unequal in terms of our role in the conversation.
Hope this gave a little extra perspective!
Maik Frank
Maik is a PCC Executive Coach and the founder of IntelliCoach.com. He has coached and trained over 400 People Leaders to improve their communication skills and offers guaranteed measurable growth to his clients. He also hosts the Coaching Leader Podcast.
Follow me
Get 1 Coaching Skills per Week
Every Sunday, we pick a tool, idea or skill from our paid courses and share it for free in our 1% Better Newsletter! You get practical things to apply right away in your upcoming conversations!
Feedback from our Readers:
"I am inspired to thank you for the valuable input that arrives in the inbox every week. Every Sunday, I take something from it for the coming week – thank you for that!" (Joachim H.)
"Super helpful. I'm in this position mentioned in the newsletter at the moment with a new coworker. I've used the suggested line with a level of success! I'll give this a go this week as well." (Mark D.)
"This is golden, Maik! You read my mind with this newsletter. Thank for you many times!" (Mubina A.)
🏢 IntelliCoach Pte Ltd.
Based in Singapore
UEN 201814680E
🔗 Contact Us
👥 About us
We create a world where every People Leader knows how to coach their team members. We give Leaders and Teams a magical toolkit to increase their performance and growth.