πŸ’‘ \"Yes\" doesn't mean they got it

πŸ•‘ 3 min Read

I caught myself this week, on a video call, just about to ask: "Does that make sense?"

I stopped. I knew exactly what would happen. They'd say yes. And we'd find out two days later that nothing had made sense at all.

Here's what I think: leaders ask the wrong closing question almost every time. We say "Do you understand?" or "Was it useful?" - and we get a reflex yes. Then we move on, confident, and surprised when execution drifts.

THE STRUCTURAL PROBLEM

A "yes" answer is socially cheap. Saying "no, I'm lost" is embarrassing. In hierarchical settings - and especially where saving face matters - it's even costlier. So people nod, smile, and we mistake their politeness for clarity.

Worse: even slightly open questions like "How useful was it?" invite one-word evasions. "Very." Done. Move on. No data.

THE FIX: PERFORM, DON'T CONFIRM

The fix is small but sharp: ask the person to perform their understanding, not confirm it.

  • Instead of "Do you understand?" -> "Could you quickly summarize the next steps as you see them?"

  • Instead of "Was this useful?" -> "What's the one thing you found most useful today?"

  • Instead of "Got it?" -> "What's your key takeaway from this discussion?"

Notice what changed. The reflex "yes" is no longer available. They have to construct something. And the moment they start constructing, you instantly see the gap between what you said and what they heard. πŸ’‘

TWO DESIGN TRICKS

  1. Lead with "What", not "How."
"What is the one thing.." beats "How well did you understand.." because "what" demands content, not a judgment.

  2. Constrain the answer.
Asking for "the one thing" or "the top two steps" is friendlier than "tell me everything" β€” and gives you sharper data.

A WORD OF CARE

This only works in a trust-rich environment. In a low-trust setting, even a great question can feel like a trap. Use a coaching tone, not a quiz tone.

So.. next time you're about to ask "Does that make sense?" - pause. Try "What's the one thing you'll take away?" instead.

Maik

Maik Frank

Maik is a PCC Executive Coach and the founder of IntelliCoach.com. He has coached and trained over 400 People Leaders to improve their communication skills and offers guaranteed measurable growth to his clients. He also hosts the Coaching Leader Podcast.

Follow me

πŸ”— LinkedIn

Get 1 Coaching Skills per Week

Every Sunday, we pick a tool, idea or skill from our paid courses and share it for free in our 1% Better Newsletter! You get practical things to apply right away in your upcoming conversations!

Feedback from our Readers:

"I am inspired to thank you for the valuable input that arrives in the inbox every week. Every Sunday, I take something from it for the coming week – thank you for that!" (Joachim H.)

"Super helpful. I'm in this position mentioned in the newsletter at the moment with a new coworker. I've used the suggested line with a level of success! I'll give this a go this week as well." (Mark D.)

"This is golden, Maik! You read my mind with this newsletter. Thank for you many times!" (Mubina A.)

Comment Box is loading comments...

🏒 IntelliCoach Pte Ltd.

7 Temasek Boulevard #12-07

Suntec Tower One

Singapore 038987 UEN 201814680E

πŸ”— Contact Us

Send us a Message!

πŸ‘₯ About us

We create a world where every People Leader knows how to coach their team members. We give Leaders and Teams a magical toolkit to increase their performance and growth.